Aluminum vs Steel Fence - The Pros & Cons - A Guide for ...

Making the choice between aluminum and steel for your fencing needs is a significant decision. Both materials are outstanding options regarding aesthetics, long-lasting durability, and low maintenance requirements.

If you wish to gather more details, please visit our website.

Both aluminum and steel fences require minimal upkeep, allowing you to spend your time enjoying your outdoor space rather than maintaining it. Compared to wrought iron, they offer an elegant solution for security needs without straining your budget.

However, understanding the key differences between aluminum and steel is crucial when determining the best material for your home. This guide explores the three major factors you should consider when weighing your options between aluminum and steel fences.

1) Durability: Aluminum vs Steel

In comparison to conventional fencing materials such as wood and chain link, both aluminum and steel provide exceptional durability.

These materials are designed to withstand the elements. Aluminum is especially resistant to corrosion and will not rust. On the other hand, while steel can rust, it is protected with a coating that makes it nearly maintenance-free (for instance, Ameristar ornamental steel fencing).

If your primary concern is security, especially if you have active children or pets, you might find a steel fence more suitable. Steel, being a higher-strength material, is manufactured using a welded construction method that reinforces its already robust nature.

Additionally, opting for durable materials like aluminum or steel is advisable when considering protective pool fencing.

2) Style: Aluminum vs Steel

Both aluminum and ornamental steel fences come in many styles, albeit aluminum provides a wider range of color choices.

If matching your home’s style and color holds paramount importance, aluminum fencing may be the ideal option. For instance, Elite Ornamental Aluminum Fencing is offered in seven standard colors, and you can even request custom colors. In contrast, steel fences typically come in a more limited selection (usually black and bronze).

Regardless of the material chosen, both aluminum and steel fences can be enhanced with various styling options and accessories, including decorative finials, caps, and unique picket designs, reminiscent of the elegance and sophistication of wrought iron without the associated costs.

3) Cost: Aluminum vs Steel

Now, what about the costs associated with aluminum versus steel fences?

In comparison to high-end wrought iron fencing and upkeep-intensive alternatives like wood, aluminum and steel fencing present remarkable value. While steel is generally more expensive due to its reinforced welded structure, investing a bit more initially in either option promises considerable savings in the long run.

The ornamental steel and aluminum fences provided by Maintenance-Free Outdoor Solutions come with protective coatings tailored to reduce maintenance requirements and safeguard your investment against natural elements.

Such low-maintenance solutions, combined with visual appeal, can significantly enhance your home's resale value, ultimately maximizing your return on investment in a steel or aluminum fence.

Protecting your purchase is crucial, which is why many reputable manufacturers offer limited lifetime warranties on their fences. Keep this aspect in mind during your fence shopping.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some common questions homeowners ask when considering aluminum or steel fences.

Are Aluminum Fences Strong?

Contrary to common belief, they are stronger than many realize.

Although not as robust as steel or wrought iron options, standard residential aluminum fence rails can typically withstand about 350 lbs. of pressure.

If industrial-grade fence models are selected, expect even higher weight resistance.

Will an Aluminum Fence Rust?

No, aluminum does not rust, making it an excellent maintenance-free fencing choice.

Since aluminum lacks iron or steel components, it does not react to moisture or oxygen in the same manner as other metal fences.

Nevertheless, quality iron and steel options are typically coated with protective finishes to prevent rust and ensure structural integrity.

Is Aluminum Fencing Expensive?

Aluminum fencing tends to be somewhat pricier than other fencing types.

According to HomeAdvisor, aluminum fences cost roughly $26 per linear foot, while vinyl averages about $17/sq ft and wood around $12/sq ft.

However, it is crucial to consider more than just initial costs.

For example, aluminum fencing incurs significantly lower upkeep costs compared to traditional wood options, which require cleaning, paint touch-ups, and maintenance every few years to preserve their appearance.

In contrast, a well-constructed aluminum fence can last between 30 and 40 years, generally requiring only periodic rinsing with a hose. This longevity showcases that spending slightly more initially on an aluminum fence may be the wiser financial decision over time.

For a detailed breakdown of expenses, check out our guide on aluminum fence costs.

Aluminum vs Steel Fence - Which is Superior?

So, when debating steel or aluminum fences, which stands out as the superior choice?

Ultimately, it aligns with your specific needs and preferences.

When it comes to durability, steel is capable of enduring more wear and tear compared to aluminum, thanks to its welded construction.

Nevertheless, aluminum boasts resistance to oxidation and does not typically rust, unlike steel (unless it is coated).

In terms of style, aluminum delivers a wider array of color options, allowing for greater versatility in complementing various home styles and environmental aesthetics, with some custom options available. Conversely, steel tends to be limited in color choices.

Lastly, aluminum edges out steel in terms of cost, although the difference isn’t vast.

When weighing aluminum against steel fencing, your choice ultimately hinges on which factors hold the most importance to you.

Choose Maintenance-Free Outdoor Solutions for Your Fencing Needs

Unsure whether an aluminum or ornamental steel fence is right for you? Maintenance-Free Outdoor Solutions has been serving the St. Louis area with top-notch fence installations.

As a family-owned business with years of industry experience, we take pride in offering the finest American-made fencing solutions.

Considering the pros and cons surrounding aluminum versus steel fencing? We're here to assist you.

For additional information about the aluminum and steel fencing options available at Maintenance-Free Outdoor Solutions, feel free to visit our showroom or request a free, comprehensive estimate.

Still Not Decided on a Fence? Dive Into Our Ultimate Fencing Guide Ebook! Access this free resource today!

I'm A DIY'er

I need full service

I'd like a free estimate